Our Team

Mindy Eltringham

Owner / Senior Agent

Phone:

740.439.2737

Mindy has been in the Cambridge area for most of her life. She grew up with horses, showing American Saddlebreds across the country. Mindy and her husband Sam, have one son, Cole. They spend their free time with Cole on the golf course. If they are not out golfing, they can be found camping and boating with friends. The family enjoys cheering on the Ohio State Buckeyes.

 

Mindy has been with the agency for 24 years and became agency owner in 2020. She is able to write business in personal lines, commercial lines and life and disability insurance. She enjoys working with clients to help assess their needs and come up with a plan to find the right coverage.

Shannon Shiflett

Agent

Phone:

740.439.2737

Shannon moved to Cambridge from Myrtle Beach, SC. She is a licensed agent with 2 years of experience. 


Together with her husband Steve, they share three children, Parker, Payton and Saydee. 

Jacilyn Cox

Agent

Phone:

740.439.2737

Jacilyn moved to Newcomerstown, after growing up in California. She and her husband Gregory, have one son, Justin.

 

Jacilyn has been with the agency for 8 years. She is able to write business in personal lines, commercial lines and life and disability insurance and is a notary public. 

Jennifer Vincent

Marketing

Phone:

740.439.2737

Jennifer is the newest addition to Shafer Insurance with a year of industry experience. She currently handles the agency's marketing duties while continuing to train for additional opportunities.


She and her husband, Beau, have seven children. Jennifer lives in Cambridge and is an avid runner. 

Hours of Operation

Monday - Friday

8:00 am - 5:00 pm

Evenings and Saturdays by appointment.

Shafer Insurance Agency, Inc.

820 Wheeling Avenue

Cambridge, Ohio 43725

Phone: 740.439.2737

Fax: 740.439.4114

©

©

Shafer Insurance Agency, Inc. | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy